Special Education: NOT the Resource Room, the Classroom in the Trailer, or the Special School Across Town

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Does my daughter, who has an IEP, have to be served by resource classes or can she be totally in mainstream classrooms?

“Special education” under IDEA is not a place or placement or a pre-packaged program. Special education is a “service for children rather than a place where such children are sent.”

Special education is not the resource room, the classroom in the trailer, or the special school across town.

The IDEA includes a “least restrictive environment” (LRE) requirement.

LRE Requirement in IDEA

Special education services should be delivered in regular education classes (not special classes, separate schooling, or other removal from the regular ed environment) except “when the nature or severity of the disability of the child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.”

20 U. S. C. § 1412(a)(5) – See page 72 in Wrightslaw: Special Education Law or Chapter 10 – Placement in Wrightslaw: All About IEPs.

If the IEP of a student with a disability can be implemented satisfactorily with the provision of supplementary aids and services in the regular classroom in the school the student would attend if not disabled, that placement is the LRE placement for that student.

The “I” in IEP

When school personnel view special education as a “place,” they often fail to evaluate the child’s unique needs and how the school can meet these needs.

That’s the “I” in IEP. “What we have available” usually refers to one-size-fits-all programs that are not individualized to meet a child’s unique needs.

And remember, parents are members of any team that develops the IEP and decides on placement. IDEA Section 1414(e) requires that the school “…ensure that the parents of each child with a disability are members of any group that makes decision on the educational placement of their child.”

Read Parent Involvement in Placement Decisions at https://www.wrightslaw.com/blog/?p=394

More about Inclusion, LRE, and Mainstreaming at https://www.wrightslaw.com/info/lre.index.htm

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
06/30/2021 11:02 am

I was a special education teacher and dyslexia specialist for 15 years and understand the monumental task of teaching students with disabilities. During the pandemic, to maintain my sanity, I developed a program for secondary students that provides instruction for all TEKS standards while providing accommodations for all learning levels. This program includes lesson plans, answers, and PowerPoint slides for an entire school year. If anyone is interested, this program is free for the asking.

01/11/2021 7:33 am

The IDEA law didn’t matter to my district. They removed my child from the general education classroom without our knowledge and consent.

02/25/2020 11:24 am

I’m a special education teacher. Our school district removed team taught inclusive classrooms in the content areas of social studies and science. Now they are offering a drop in resource room. Is this an acceptable delivery model of LRE in IDEA? I realize it isn’t the preferred and disgruntled that students needs are not being met. Moreover, it is disappointing that students report that they don’t like the stigma of having to leave to get help identifying them as being slow. Any good research to justify going back to a more inclusive model please advise.

09/23/2019 4:49 pm

I am a special education teacher who currently servicing over 30 special education students from 5 different grade levels and three different subjects. Due to the large number of students I service, I do not have a conference period and no other assistance in the classroom. My instructional aides currently services my inclusion students and I have voiced my concerns for additional staff to meet the needs of the students. This has been an issue long before I arrived and more students are qualifying for special education services. While I have tried to meet the needs of the students, without additional help or another certified special education teacher to assist in the division of this large amount of students our students suffer. What do I do to rectify this situation?

09/24/2019 2:39 pm
Reply to  Aprile

Put this in writing and take it up the chain of command, if you have not done this.

08/27/2019 11:35 am

My son has an IEP for written expression but he does not want to be pulled out of the regular education classroom to receive Special services. He just entered middle school and feels it sets him apart. Will his IEP be completely terminated, or can he still receive accommodations in the regular classroom that are listed on his current iep without receiving direct services if we ask that he not be pulled out for services during the regular school day?

08/27/2019 12:39 pm
Reply to  Suzanne

There are other options that might meet his needs and the campus might be willing to implement. For some services students do not need to leave the class all period, &/or every day. Services could be provided before or after the school day or non-instructional times. Some schools use the co-teaching model. Some states may allow accommodations to be provided, even if the student is not receiving special ed instruction. But frequently states & districts want to do this under the Section 504 rules.

08/28/2019 9:32 pm
Reply to  Suzanne

He will need to engage in all the services and minutes that are listed in the offer of FAPE. In the services section, you can add push in or pull out in the comments section under the service (Amendment time!). But services like APE, OT, SLP services likely can’t be done in the classroom. However, unfortunately he needs to do all services or the school will be out of compliance or you can agree to remove all services.

03/20/2019 3:42 am

I moved to a district where the school doesn’t practice any kind of pull-out. The special ed teachers do only either self-contained or pop into an inclusion class for 2 hours a week. I was told that my dyslexic son now only gets 2 hours a week with a qualified special ed teacher and isn’t going to have any of the small classroom individualized learning he had in the resource room because he “isn’t severely retarded or non-verbal autistic.”

It infuriates me. Inclusion has its place. Self contained classes have a place. Moving to only either one or the other is just a way to not hire as many special ed teachers and drastically cuts the help and resources kids like mine get.

03/20/2019 3:03 pm
Reply to  Joanne

I tell parents to think long term–if you are stuck with this school district -do not waste time trusting that district to remediate your son. What are his goals (college, vocational school, etc)? Look at the goals and ensure that he receives proper instruction and even if needed assistive technology. You may need to do this on your own until you work it out with the school but don’t waste time. Talk to the disaiblity offices at your state and local colleges to see how students with dyslexia use assistive tech and accommodations. Review dyslexia summer programs for your son. Involve him so he learns to self advocate. His strength will be in recognizing his own deficits but most of all his strengths. Those strengths will help him SOAR high!!!

03/20/2019 3:23 pm
Reply to  Joanne

Placement & services are to be based on a child’s needs. It does not sound like that is the case you describe. The federal dispute resolution processes exist for situations like this. These should be described in materials the school gives parents. You can contact your state parent training and information center. http://www.parentcenterhub.org/find-your-center

03/21/2019 8:43 am
Reply to  Joanne

If your district considers someone with a severe intellectual disability and someone with autism (non-verbal or not), to be one category of learner, then I think you should find a different school district to live in!

(Sorry – I had to get that off my chest!)

As Chuck said, this is not a decision that is subject to a district policy. This is a decision made by the IEP TEAM – of which you are member. IDEA requires schools “…must ensure that a continuum of alternative placements is available to meet the needs of children with disabilities…” see IDEA Sec. 300.115 Continuum of alternative placements

How they pay for it isn’t your problem, but you could suggest they dip into their Auxiliary Services and IDEA Part B funding…they’ll figure it out!

03/05/2019 3:11 pm

Our district has an open enrollment policy that lets any student in the district open enroll in any school. Within this model, there are what they call “focus” schools, which are similar to magnet schools with special educational models. They are not charter schools but are made up entirely of students who choice in. “Focus” schools only have “resource” level of supports, whereas neighborhood schools have “intensive learning centers” AKA resource rooms. The district counsels out children with identified intellectual disabilities (including my own 4yo with Down syndrome) from attending the focus schools. We open enrolled in the Montessori school anyways, against their counsel but with support of the school principal, and wonder what our legal rights are?

03/03/2019 10:44 am

My son who is Autistic is in a private school. Son was in General Education class and then thrown into a Special Autistic Support class. I am really furious because he learns a lot from his peers. I confronted the school about his placement and they replied that the teacher and other students cannot stand him and he is interrupting their right to learn. I mentioned that my son has rights as well and I will be pulling him out of school. Their reply was oh well you can pull him out but you have to pay for the rest of the school year! What should I do?

03/05/2019 9:17 am
Reply to  April

I don’t know about the legal issue, I guess it depends on your agreement/contract with the private school when your son started.

I would also remove my child from that school. They obviously don’t deserve to have him there. The research supporting IDEA’s least restrictive environment rules is pretty well settled. “Mainstreaming” as much as possible benefits everyone, not just the student needing additional support.

We have some flexibility in our area with open enrollment and parents can choose where to send their children, or they move to exceptional districts – (and these aren’t always in affluent areas, BTW!) If you have some choice too, research different schools. Visit the school, talk to parents, invite yourself to community events — and keep fighting for your son!

Shelley G
02/28/2019 10:28 pm

I teach at a school that places children in classes based on their state assessment score. All of the students that have special education services are placed in the same class by grade level. The students are aware of this, and oftentimes I hear them saying they are “the dumb class”. Is this practice legal? If so, how is it beneficial to students?

03/01/2019 1:22 pm
Reply to  Shelley G

Students are aware of when they are being “tracked” and it impacts them. Yes, it easier to place them all in the same room to track special ed services but is it wise. I had my child removed from a lower tracked class. My child wanted college prep and had goal. The behaviors in the lower tracked classroom were alarming as they also sometimes placed behavioral students in those classes, and the teacher had no control in the classroom. I advocated that the instructional design and delivery did not comply with my child’s IEP and my child was removed ASAP and placed in a small group and received the appropriate instructional model and delivery. I also politely mentioned the word “tracking” and well the school did not want to admit that they were tracking students.

09/17/2018 9:13 pm

I’m concerned, first my daughter had no para support in her new school and now they have clustered her in all special education rooms when she can function in normal class rooms, just needs para support and adjusted assignments. She learns alot from her peers.

09/18/2018 1:04 pm
Reply to  Linda

It sounds like she was placed in a more restrictive environment without the IEP team making this decision. Your state parent training & information center can assist you. http://www.parentcenterhub.org/find-your-center

09/03/2018 7:29 pm

When changing a special education student’s schedule from a general education elective course to a special education study skills class, isn’t that placing them in a more restrictive environment?

09/05/2018 7:49 am
Reply to  Blanca

Yes; however, a study skills class may be beneficial to the child.

09/05/2018 12:04 pm
Reply to  joannie

I agree. My child’s school created a study skills class instead of putting a bunch of the kids in elective classes–that study skills class gave them the “extra” they needed to make progress and continue on into high school. It supplemented their education in addition to what they were already learning. It was a creative way to really give those kids more academics, experimental learning projects, etc. I thought it was a great idea and truly inspired the kids to higher goals–my child and others went on to college. It was a unique approach and the school district tried something new–and it worked. Most of these kids were just below scores on state assessments and LD–very creative learning objectives.

06/25/2018 11:08 am

I really like what you said about how special education services should be delivered in regular education classes and not removing the children from each other except in special circumstances. My little brother was often to be separated from his classmates and had a hard time with it since he’s very social and no danger to anyone. Thank you for the clarification on the law and how it would affect someone with his disabilities.