Feds Sue NY District for Discrimination & Violating Service Animal Requirements of ADA

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

“It is no longer acceptable – if ever it was – for a district to refuse reasonable modifications to a child who seeks to handle her own service dog … Certainly since passage of the American with Disabilities Act in 1990, such failure not only violates the dictates of conscience, it also violates the law”

On September 29 2015, the Department of Justice filed suit against the Gates-Chili Central School District for refusing to allow a third grader with disabilities to attend school with her service dog unless her parent provides a separate adult handler for the dog.

Devyn’s Story

In preschool, the district allowed Devyn to bring her dog, Hannah, to school and allowed school staff to help.

But when Devyn entered Kindergarten, the district changed their policies and procedures, and would not allow Devyn to bring Hannah to school unless her parent provided a separate adult handler.

The child’s 1:1 aide or other school staff were no longer allowed to help.

Jumping Through the Unlawful Hoop

Devyn’s parents have paid a handler $1,400 a month (about $17,000 a year) to accompany Hannah and Devyn to school.

The handler spends about 15 minutes a day “handling” Hannah.

DOJ Orders School to Reverse Its Policy & Pay Damages

After a long, thorough investigation, the Department of Justice issued a letter of finding in April 2015.

DOJ ordered the school district to reverse its policy and pay compensatory damages to the family for injuries they suffered because the district failed to comply with the ADA.


  • Complaint
  • Letter of Findings
  • article about legal fees
  • details about the case

Feds Sue NY School District for Discrimination & Violating Service Animal Requirements of ADA  by Pamela Darr Wright, MA, MSW & Peter W.D. Wright, Esq.


2015 FAQs about Service Animals and DOJ Guidance in Can the School Refuse to Allow a Service Dog

  1. What happens if my school in Augusta has students with IEPs that require a one on one and the county board of Education special Ed. Department refuses to hire required one and ones for students, putting teachers and other students at risk.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Please help us defeat spam. Thank you. *