The Wrightslaw Way

to Special Education Law and Advocacy

The Wrightslaw Way random header image

The Negative Effects of Separating Children with Disabilities

by Wrightslaw

Inclusion:  What does the research say?

There is a strong research base to support the education of children with disabilities alongside their non-disabled peers.

Although separate classes, with lower student to teacher ratios, controlled environments, and specially trained staff would seem to offer benefits to a child with a disability, research fails to demonstrate the effectiveness of such programs (Lipsky, 1997; Sailor, 2003).

There is mounting evidence that, other than a smaller class size, “there is little that is special about the special education system,” and that the negative effects of separating children with disabilities from their peers far outweigh any benefit to smaller classes (Audette & Algozzine, 1997).    – from What Does the Research Say about Inclusion? by Dr. Kathleen Whitbread.

Kathleen Whitbread, Ph.D., is an associate professor of education at the University of Saint Joseph in West Hartford, CT, where she teaches graduate and undergraduate courses in special education.

Parents as Equal Partners in the IEP Process

IEP and Inclusion Tips for Parents and Teachers by Anne Eason and Kathleen Whitbread provides parents with tips and strategies for making inclusive education a reality for their children.

Parents can use these strategies to be more active participants in the IEP process and to develop meaningful education programs for their children

These strategies are not expensive. They do not require parents to obtain degrees in education or advocacy.

IEP Tips offers common sense approaches about how to advocate effectively for children with disabilities. The book also provides information about evaluating student progress.

“It is our hope that these tips will prove useful for families as they advocate for their children, and will allow parents to come the IEP table as true and equal partners in the IEP process.”

What Does the Research Say about Inclusion? is included in IEP and Inclusion Tips for Parents and Teachers.


Print Friendly

Tags:   · · 6 Comments

Leave a Reply

6 Comments on "The Negative Effects of Separating Children with Disabilities"


Does anyone know if there is a legal maximum percentile of children with special needs in the general education classroom? I have a 1st grade child with dyslexia and add that is struggling to keep up in a class where 1/3 of the demographic have An LD of some kind – lots of disruptions. the ratio looks great on paper, 18:1, but not so great when we consider the complex nature of the class.

I imagine it varies by state. I’m in MA.


Children raised with children with disabilities in their classes and schools grow up to be more accepting of individuals with disabilities, a huge advantage to inclusion.

Mike the Psych

Morning, sounds like that class is less than ideal! Grouping kiddos is the norm though. We group students in grades, and group routinely for honors courses too. Grouping by ability is useful to narrow the range of differentiation needed by the teacher and can really help to focus on needs of students, if they have similar deficits.

Of course all of this is only useful if groupings are made appropriately. Much like groupings for RtI intervention groups, you simply cannot throw all the lowest achieving kids in one spot. It is definitely something to keep an eye on.