Wrightslaw l No Child Left Behind l IDEA 2004 l Fetaweb l Yellow Pages for Kids l Harbor House Law Press
 Home >  News  > > Witte v. Clark County NV - Court Issues New Decision in School Brutality Case (Sept 23, 2002)


The Special Ed Advocate
It's Unique ... and Free!

Enter your email address below:

 

2015 Training Programs

Jan 16 - School District, LA

Jan 24 - Corpus Christi, TX

Jan 24 - Pensacola, FL

Jan 31 - Champaign, IL

Feb 19 - Lincroft, NJ

Feb 24 - Knoxville, TN

Feb 26 - Memphis, TN

Full Schedule

Be a Hero ...

 Jason at Ft. Benning
... to a Hero
Learn more

Wrightslaw

Home
Topics from A-Z
Free Newsletter
Seminars & Training
Consultations
Yellow Pages for Kids
Press Room
FAQs
Sitemap

Books & Training

Wrightslaw Books & DVDs
Wrightslaw Storesecure store lock
  Advocate's Store
  Student Bookstore
  Exam Copies
Training Center
Bulk Discounts
New! Military Discounts
Mail & Fax Orders

Advocacy Library

Articles
Doing Your Homework
Ask the Advocate
FAQs
Newsletter Archives
Summer School Series
Success Stories
Tips

Law Library

Articles
Caselaw
IDEA 2004
No Child Left Behind
McKinney-Vento Homeless
FERPA
Section 504
Fed Court Complaints

Topics

Advocacy
ADD/ADHD
Allergy/Anaphylaxis
Assistive Technology
Autism Spectrum
Behavior & Discipline
Bullying
College/Continuing Ed
Damages
Discrimination
Due Process
Early Intervention (Part C)
Eligibility
ESY
Evaluations
FAPE
Flyers
Future Planning
Harassment
High-Stakes Tests
Homeless Children
IDEA 2004
Identification & Child Find
IEPs
ISEA
Juvenile Justice
Law School & Clinics
Letters & Paper Trails
LRE/Inclusion
Mediation
Military / DOD
No Child Left Behind
NCLB Directories
NCLB Law & Regs
Parental Protections
PE and Adapted PE
Privacy & Records
Procedural Safeguards
Progress Monitoring
Reading
Related Services
Research Based Instruction
Response to Intervention (RTI)
Restraints/Abuse
Retention
Retaliation
School Report Cards
Section 504
Self-Advocacy
Teachers & Principals
Transition
Twice Exceptional (2e)
VA Special Education

Resources & Directories

Advocate's Bookstore
Advocacy Resources
Directories
  Disability Groups
  International
  State DOEs
  State PTIs
Free Flyers
Free Pubs
Free Newsletters
Legal & Advocacy
Glossaries
   Legal Terms
   Assessment Terms
Best School Websites

 

Witte v. Clark County & Eason v. Clark County
New Decision in School Brutality Cases

According to the pleadings filed in March 1998 seeking monetary damages, Shawn Witte was forced to eat his own vomit as a disciplinary measure.

Shawn has been diagnosed with Tourette Syndrome, asthma, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder and emotional problems.

Shawn has tics. To control his tics, school personnel pinned Shawn to the ground with his arms behind his back. He was choked. An emergency room doctor reported bruising “consistent (with) neck strangulation.”

Shawn’s legs are physically deformed, which “makes it difficult for him to sustain long durations of running or running very fast.” School personnel forced Shawn to run on a treadmill with heavy weights on his feet.

If Shawn “told his mother or anyone about these abusive practices . . . (he) would go to jail for being a liar and/or that he would be taken away from his mother.” (Paragraph 39 of the Complaint)

In November 2000, the U. S. District court dismissed this case for the second time. The Court ordered the parents to pay school district personnel nearly $7,000 for legal costs. Again, the attorneys who represented Shawn appealed to the U. S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.

The court heard oral argument on February 11, 2002 and issued a decision on September 10, 2002.

Witte I

On December 3, 1999, we sent an Alert about the Witte v. Clark County NV school brutality case.

In March, 1998, Shawn Witte’s parent filed suit in the U. S. District Court against school officials. She sought monetary damages and requested a jury trial. The alleged facts of abuse are horrible.

A trial on the merits has not been held. Only time will prove the truth of the allegations.

The District Court dismissed the case because the parent failed to request a due process hearing and instead filed suit in Court. Although Shawn was receiving services under IDEA, the well-drafted Federal Court complaint did not allege a violation of IDEA.

In prior cases, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals held that money damages are not available for IDEA claims. If a parent fails to exhaust administrative remedies, i.e., request a due process hearing, Courts are “without jurisdiction.” Because these parents filed suit in Court without first requesting a due process hearing, the case was dismissed by the District Court.

The parents appealed the dismissal to the U. S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. In December 1999, that Court reversed the District Court and remanded the case back to the District Court for trial.

Witte II

When the case was heard again, the U. S. District “dismissed all claims against all defendants on the ground that defendants were immune from suit in federal court under the Eleventh Amendment and subsequently awarded costs of $6,879.87 to defendants.”

The Eleventh Amendment has been construed to bar suits by citizens against their states.

Witte v. Clark County School District is a damages case brought under Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act. Witte does not focus on issues of an appropriate education under IDEA. Dollar damages are not available under IDEA. States are not immune from suits under IDEA.

While individual states may be immune in some types of cases under the Eleventh Amendment, school districts, municipalities, and local units of government are usually not immune. In a prior case, the Ninth Circuit found that a California school district was immune because of the unique nature of local and state funding of public school education in California.

In a new decision issued on September 10, 2002, the Ninth Circuit discusses immunity and explains why school districts in one state may be immune while districts in another state are not:

"The central question is whether the Clark County School District is ‘an arm of the state,” entitled to Eleventh Amendment immunity . . . The Supreme Court has mentioned in passing that the Eleventh Amendment does not afford ‘local school boards’ immunity suit . . .”

The District Court ordered the parents to pay the defendants almost $7,000 for their legal costs. When the Court of Appeals reversed this decision, they also dismissed the award for costs against the parents.

During the last appeal, the Witte case was merged with another similar case on behalf of Derrick Eason who also attended Varsity School in Clark County, NV. The case is now styled Derrick Eason v. Clark County School District.

When you read last week’s ruling in Shawn’s case, you will also learn about Derrick.


Links

Complaint in Shawn Witte's case (March 2, 1998)

Decision #1 by the U. S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit (Dec 2, 1999)

Wrightslaw Alert about Shawn Witte’s case (December 3, 1999)

Update on Witte case (Dec 7, 1999)

Key Issues in Witte v. Clark County School District by Pete Wright (Dec 16, 1999)

Decision #2 by U. S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit (September 10, 2002)

 

Email Newsletter icon, E-mail Newsletter icon, Email List icon, E-mail List icon The Special Ed Advocate: It's Free!

 

Wrightslaw: Special Education Law, 2nd Edition, by Pam and Pete Wright
About the Book

Wrightslaw: All About IEPs
About the Book

Wrightslaw: All About Tests and Assessments
About the Book

Surviving Due Process: Stephen Jeffers v. School Board
About the DVD Video

 

Copyright 1998-2014, Peter W. D. Wright and Pamela Darr Wright. All rights reserved.

Contact Us | Press Mission l Our Awards l Privacy Policy l Disclaimer l Site Map

What's New!

Now Shipping!

Wrightslaw: All About Tests and Assessments
About the Book

Check it out!

Wrightslaw Store

The Advocate's Store

Get Help!

Blog the Wrightslaw

Wrightslaw on Facebook

Find us on Facebook

Wrightslaw Books

Student Discounts

Military Discounts


Wrightslaw: All About IEPs

About the Book
To Order

Wrightslaw: Special Education Law, 2nd Edition, by Pam and Pete Wright
About the Book
To Order


About the Book

To Order


Surviving Due Process: Stephen Jeffers v. School Board

About the DVD Video
To Order


To Order


Wrightslaw: No Child Left Behind

About the Book
To Order

Wrightslaw Multimedia Training


Understanding Your Child's
Test Scores (1.5 hrs)

Understanding Your Child's Test Scores

Learn More
To Order
Retail Price: $
24.95
Wrightslaw Special: $14.95

Special Education Law & Advocacy Training
(6.5 hrs)


Wrightslaw WebEx Special Education Law & Training Program (6.5 hrs)


Learn More
To Order
Retail Price: $99.95
Wrightslaw Special: $49.95